Jackson CarrollCOMPASS
Jackson Carroll

Moving to Nashville: where your budget gets you

What I tell everyone who asks me about moving here. Takes about 3 minutes to read.

What your budget gets you

$600K to $800K
The NationsWhere a lot of people buy their first home at this price.
Sylvan ParkEither a lot with a home that needs to come down, or a well-kept home that's older and smaller.
Around $1M
12 SouthA 5 to 10 year old home, probably 3 bedrooms.
Charlotte Park or the NationsSomething newer.
Green HillsSomething older.
Joelton or Whites CreekAlmost double the house and the land.
Luxury
Belle MeadeNew construction runs about $1,500 a square foot. The land alone is about $2M an acre.

Why people are moving here

Your money goes further

About $1M buys you:

New YorkAbout 1,200 sq ft. A two-bedroom apartment.
Los AngelesAbout 1,400 sq ft. A small two- or three-bedroom house.
NashvilleOver 3,000 sq ft.

No state income tax

Tennessee has 0% state income tax. Making around $400K in California or New York, that's roughly a 10% saving.

My estimate, not tax advice. Check your own numbers with your CPA.

What surprises people

Property taxes keep going up

In Davidson County, if your appraisal comes in higher than your home is worth, you can file a rebuttal with an appraisal or comps of homes that sold.

Zillow is only an estimate

It knows location and square footage. It doesn't know your finishes, your layout or what your backyard is worth to a buyer.

Same neighborhood, different prices

Even in a small neighborhood, one street can sell for more than the next. Floor plan, lot and finishes all move the number.

If you have a car you care about

Look for garage ceilings of at least 12 feet (room for a lift) and pivot-motor doors, not a motor hanging over the middle. And watch for the new speed hump on Hobbs Road.

Buying new construction

Check these three things first

  1. The builder's reputation. If people you know had a bad time with their warranty process, skip them.
  2. The small details. Molding, light fixtures, even the can lights. Six-inch baseboards and flush floor vents are signs of a quality build.
  3. What other new homes nearby are worth. Builders price on their margin. You buy on what the home is actually worth.

How I find new builds before they're listed

  1. Narrow down the neighborhoods you want.
  2. Look at every home sold to a developer there in the last year or two. That's what's going up next.
  3. Pull the permits on Nashville ePermits to find the builder and owner. Then ask: are you selling, or is this a custom home?
  4. Write the contract so you're protected. Don't get stuck with a non-refundable deposit on a home you never get.

Homes most buyers never see

How we find homes that never hit the market:

Three recent ones

12 South, $2.35MAbout $100K under appraised value. The buyer had looked for a month. We called the agents active in 12 South and found one that checked every box.
12 South, $4MThe family had seen 15 homes. I called a builder I'd worked with, who had one under construction.
Green Hills, $2.15MThey wanted one neighborhood, with a pool. We called every homeowner there who had one and found someone ready to sell.

$80M sold in Greater Nashville since 2023. $34M of it never hit the market.

Want homes that fit your budget?

Send me when you're moving and your price range. I'll send you homes that fit. I answer these myself.

Message me on Instagram Call 615-856-1492
Message Jackson